Publius Pundit
Articles Archive

« Previous · Home · Next »

Reality Check

Filed under: Middle East

Those who hoped that once Hamas will lead the government it would be a new period of tahydya (calm) and prosperity for the Palestinians have now the proof that they were deadly wrong. Hamas slogans were powerful and correct to a certain extent. Fatah is the personification of corruption. But Hamas is the incarnation of nihilism.

They do not want a state, two states or three states solution. They want to keep killing Jews and apparently they have no problem in killing their own kind either. The difference between Fatah and Hamas is not their objectives but rather their tactics.

President Abbas sacked the Hamas led government. But that does not change a thing on the ground. Hamas has taken Gaza. Hamas is the elected government of the Palestinians.

What more can be said? Except that the Palestinians have what they wanted all along. Outside Israel people often excuse Palestinian violence by saying it is a reaction to the pressure, but hostile Arabs surround Israel, Hezbollah's missiles threaten it, Iran threatens it with a a nuclear
attack and Palestinian Qassams land weekly in Israel's towns and villages.

This is the cult of violence and death preached by Hamas. Racism, hate and murder seem to be a national obsession. It is a deeply troubling fact but that is the reality and we have to call a spade a spade.

In the past few years Iran and Syria have been constantly undermining any chance for a Palestinian coalition. They have been paying Hamas not to negotiate or recognize Israel, not to release the kidnapped soldier, not to form a unity government with Abbas. Hezbollah trained
Hamas and Syria offered safe heaven to individuals such as Khaled Meshal.

What the Palestinians as a people failed to see or admit is that their interests are being used by Arab Muslims and by Muslims for decades. No one cares about them period. They are and always were proxies in the war of others to gain regional preeminence, to escape isolation, justice, to gain better deals from the West etc.

Hamas is only leading the Palestinians into more despair and misery. Palestinians do not need a savior. They never needed one. They need to stand united, end terror, negotiate with Israel a lasting peace, not a hudna and start building a nation. If they want to be recognized as a people and not as a bunch of criminals they need to start acting like one.

When the Iranian money and support ends, and it eventually will, the Palestinians will be even further from having their own state than they are now. The world has spent 59 years giving Palestinian Arabs a chance. And what has it gotten the world? For that matter, what has
it gotten Palestinian Arabs? They used all this time trying to kill as many Jews as possible and obliterate Israel instead of building lives for themselves.

When Israel withdrew from Gaza, Hamas and those who elected it had a chance to prove that they are indeed capable of running it, that they can deliver what they promised. Has anyone seen what the Palestinians have done with Gaza? State-of-the-art greenhouses that used to provide food and products that were high on demand on the international market have now been turned into tunnel openings.

The terror groups will never allow Palestine to be a separate entity because they do not benefit from it. They do not want to work for themselves and for their own people; they simply want to keep on stealing the money the international community is sending and terrorize the Jews.

The Palestinians should accept written agreements, end all acts of terror, violence and the incitement to terror. If and when they will do it only then the international community should help them financially. Meanwhile let their Iranian and Syrian sponsors pay. Let the oil rich Arab states send money to them if they want, but the US, Israel and EU money should not be used to support and enhance a terrorist, lawlessness entity. It is illogical and it will cause more deaths and destruction in Israel, Gaza and West Bank on the long term.

Terrorist actions have terrible consequences for all involved parties. The only way to get away from the vicious cycle of violence is for the Palestinians to get out of the Islamic propaganda box and be responsible.

Social Bookmarking:
Del.icio.us this del.icio.us | digg this digg | Add to Technorati technorati | StumbleUpon Toolbar stumble upon | Furl this furl | Reddit this reddit

Comments


JoeMorgan says:

Zionism is neo-Nazism. The Palestinians have endured two generations of Zionist brutality and attrocities. When freedom fighters like Hamas fight back against this brutality they are called terrorists.


Manuela says:

JoeMorgan: I appreciate your feedback, but I strongly disagree. We too in the West should be thinking out of the box; not zionism is the problem right now. These "freedom fighters" had their chance with Gaza. Gaza was not under occupation anymore, yet they continued to attack Israel. How do you explain that? And if its that good to live under Hamas why do hundreds of Gazans flee and ask for help from their biggest enemy, Israel? Where is Jordan and Egypt's help? Why do not they help their blood brothers?


Harold says:

Manuela,
I am reading these two comments about one month after they were written. Hope it's not too late, but just to let you know, this "JoeMorgan" is a notorious Holocaust denier (surprise!) who writes lots of letters to papers, as well as trolling on blogs. He has defended numerous Holocaust deniers and has portrayed them as poor, "persecuted," "misunderstood" people who are being unjustly set upon. I'm proud to expose him to you as a vile racist who promulgates his filth everywhere he can.


Manuela says:

I appreciate the heads up. It is never too late to expose someone like JoeMorgan.


RR says:

It must be bad to be the victims of sacred cows. The sacred cows keep attacking you and want to destroy you, yet you lift a finger against them in self-defence and you are guilty of sacrilege. Thus, of the Palestinians, "They want to keep killing Jews"; not because the sacred Jews attacked them and destroyed their country where they were 90% of the population in 1920, but just because they are Jews.

"This is the cult of violence and death preached by Hamas", we are told. "Racism, hate and murder seem to be a national obsession." To assume that they "just want to keep killing Jews" for nothing of course is not racism, because the Jews are sacred cows.

As Israel was born of a brutal campaign of ethnic cleansing and its leaders refuse to accept Palestine or its right to exist, there was no need to "have been paying Hamas not to negotiate or recognize Israel" as Israel demands impossible conditions for negotiations, as intended, as they want no meaningful negotiations. No one demanded that the IRA accept Northern Ireland's Right to Exist and no one demanded that Alija Izetbegovic accept Republika Srpska's Right to Exist as a condition for negotiations. The purpose of this unusual demand is for the Palestinians to surrender all cards before the game starts while Israel keeps all of theirs. The Right to Exist of Israel in borders of its choosing which it refuses to define, and the de-facto legitimisation of the ethnic cleansing of 1948 and that recognition goes one way and the right to violence only belongs to Israel, these things are to prejudice any so-called talks to make them impossible other than in the context of total surrender to be enforced by brutality by Israel and collaborators like Dahlan.

"Hamas is only leading the Palestinians into more despair and misery", we are told. So, they expelled 750,000 people in 1948 and have banned them and their descendents from returning home?

"Palestinians do not need a savior. They never needed one. They need to stand united, end terror, negotiate with Israel a lasting peace". For Israel, this means nothing more than total surrender and accepting of permanent ethnic cleansing.

"The world has spent 59 years giving Palestinian Arabs a chance", we are told. Israel's membership in the UN was conditioned on its allowing the expelled Palestinians to return and this was not followed. In 1920, the world allowed an invasion of their homeland by those determined to destroy them.

It's amusing to see mention of the "state-of-the-art greenhouses that used to provide food and products that were high on demand on the international market"; last year's crop rotted at the checkpoints courtesy of Israel, with not a penny in compensation for that as is the case with all Israeli destruction, amply funded by the American taxpayers.


Harold says:

As long as folks like RR keep demonizing one side in this conflict (and hatemongers like RR happen to enjoy demonizing Jews and Israel), there will not be peace.


Dean says:

I love how the one side that has chief oppressive and executive power in Palestine is considered perfect and incorruptible, and any offense to that state is an offense not to an unjust, oppressive theocracy - but the Jews.

Here is the biggest lie:
"The world has spent 59 years giving Palestinian Arabs a chance."

How can someone type that shit with a straight face?? It has clearly been the opposite way around - we have given the Israeli state so long to have a chance. It has failed at respecting humanity in even the most basic of forms.

This article is disgusting; Israelis reading it would clearly be offended. It acts as if they are somehow incapable of choices in their actions, that theirs is a response to a powerful and oppressive Palestine. All talk of the peace process is as if the Palestinians can only be addressed.

Once again, "the Jews" are the helpless objects of someone elses hatred and cannot be called upon for their own salvation. The difference this time is that Hitler is gone and those Jews that do face the fear of Palestinian terror are pawns in the game of the U.S. / Israel's power.

The Jewish people are an autonomous people; they can make choices. So can the Palestinians. I'm pround that I'm not so callous as to call random Palestinian terror a nature of Palestinian people, or Israeli state terror the fault of Israelis in general. Even more so that I don't think "Islam versus Judaism." This article is little more than hatred, not only for it's primary target, the Palestinains (and Arabs), but also for the Jewish and Israeli people by conflating the two and implying that they are powerless.

The vast majority on both 'sides' want peace and freedom for each other. Those who seek to cast all of one or the other in a negative light are simple-minded bigots. I am proud to say I don't mourn for the victims of Palestinian suicide bombers or Israeli incursions any less due to my politics. And I sure as hell won't blame people for wanting to be free.


Manuela says:

Dean if it is true that MOST ppl on both sides want peace, then how come they still fight?

Your reading is superficial if you think that I hate either side. I don't. I just look at the big picture and see what has been accomplished or not. Since 1948 Israel's existence as a nation has been under attack. My only suggestion is to go to the source and find out what some Arab Muslims (MB, its wing Hamas, HizbAllah) want and how they plan to accomplish it. An easy start is Naim Qassem's latest book (http://www.amazon.com/Hizbullah-Story-Within-Naim-Qassem/dp/0863565174

Israelis and Palestinians are autonomous to a certain extent as any other people. Like it or not we all live surrounded by neighbors. Depending on each nation short/long term interests the gov maps a line of foreign policy. Can you tell me what has been Fatah and/or Hamas foreign policy towards Israel in the past 10 years? If they seek peace their actions surely show something different.

I just think that Palestinians are doomed with such incompetent and/or fanatic leadership.


Dean says:

Why should I tell you how these terror organizations seek peace? I don't see that in them. I also recognize Israel as terroristic, however, and that's the point. Israel is an organization the United States has enough power to sway in regards to military action - all we have to do is slow - or threaten to slow - the military funding. I don't see how an inoculous Israeli state would create more suicide bombers, but I do see that ignoring the obvious answers to these problems or pretending that only one side must change is only going to cause more strife for the people of both nations.

And I guarantee you that they all want peace. Not only have I seen statistics to this end, but the common knowledge of humans is enough to see this. The U.S. population may have once supported the Iraq war, but out of fear that not attacking the nation would make peace LESS likely. Of course, the soldiers and civilians on the ground get caught up in these wars which amount to greed. The difference with the Israeli situation is that it is always the Palestinians being blamed for their own oppression, which is sick.



Post a comment


(will not be published)



Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)




TrackBack

TrackBack URL: http://publiuspundit.com/mt/contages.cgi/234